Nolte: Afghanistan Is Not Worth One More American Life

ELWOOD, ILLINOIS - AUGUST 13: The remains of U.S. Army Spc. Michael Nance arrive for burial at Abraham Lincoln National Cemetery on August 13, 2019 in Elwood, Illinois. Nance, who was assigned to Company B, 1st BN, 505th Parachute Infantry Regiment 3rd BCT, 82nd Airborne, died July 29 of wounds …
Scott Olson/Getty

Here’s the dirty little secret about Afghanistan… The people of Afghanistan, you know, the people we are trying to liberate…? Well, nowhere near enough of them want to be liberated. I’m sure some of them do, but not enough. Like Russia and Iraq, decades of authoritarianism have broken that country beyond repair.

We tried.

Honest to God, we tried.

We’ve spent somewhere around $2 trillion failing-to-liberate Afghanistan.

According to one group still counting, since that war began in 2001, there have been 2448 American fatalities in our campaign to fail-to-liberate Afghanistan. This year, seven American have already died.

What more can we do?

What’s left to try?

Why are 12,000 Americans still in a no-win, 19-year-old campaign where seven have already been picked off this year?

I’ll never take off the hair shirt of backing these wars, and doing so as stridently as I did, and being so goddamned wrong… And yes, under the delusion there’s a small “d” democrat buried in everyone’s soul, I backed the nation building. In the long run, I believed that if we could protect the people of Iraq and Afghanistan and teach them to fight, that just like Americans in 1776 and the South Vietnamese two hundred years later, they would be willing to fight and die for freedom.

Well, they’re not willing. Their human spirit is broken and no amount of money or dead Americans can fix the human spirit.

It’s time to go, and I don’t care if we make peace with the Taliban, I don’t care if we make peace with the devil, I don’t care if we just get up and leave without making peace with anyone… It’s time to go.

The sad, little secret is this… We can no longer win a ground war. Our magnificent troops can win battles. Our magnificent troops can remove an invading aggressor, like Saddam Hussein from Kuwait. But we simply cannot win against a guerilla campaign when we’re fighting fanatics in the form of revolutionary Islamists or communists.

They never give up.

They don’t care about casualties.

All we can do is bomb the shit out of them, which is what we’ll need to do if Afghanistan goes back to their old ways of harboring international terrorists.

U.S. President Donald Trump (L) and Vice President Mike Pence (C) observe the dignified transfer of two U.S. soldiers, killed in Afghanistan, at Dover Air Force Base in Dover, Delaware.  The two soldiers have been identified as Sgt. 1st Class Javier Jaguar Gutierrez, 28, of San Antonio, TX, and Sgt. 1st Class Anonio Rey Rodriguez, 28, of Las Cruces, New Mexico. ( JIM WATSON/AFP via Getty Images)

You know who had this exactly right? George H.W. Bush, the first President Bush, the guy who pushed Saddam out of Kuwait but was smart enough not to chase Saddam into Baghdad.

Bush Sr. caught a lot of flak for letting Saddam go, but how wise was that in hindsight?

And I don’t blame Bush Jr. for trying. The idea of building democracies in the Middle East was a noble one. Imagine if it had succeeded.

But it didn’t.

What I can’t get over are the Neocon dead-enders who continue to argue we need to stay. Never Trumper Stephen Hayes, who couldn’t even rebuild the Weekly Standard, is mad.

David French got a head start being mad five months ago.

Naturally, John Bolton is mad, as is Rep. Liz Cheney (R-WY)… the usual suspects. But no one offers an alternative, I mean other than what hasn’t worked over the last 19 years.

I was 35 years-old when the war in Afghanistan began. Today, I’m 54 — and hopefully a little wiser.

Babies born when that war began have already graduated high school.

The primary argument against withdrawal appears to be it will create a vacuum like the one Obama created for ISIS with his disastrous withdrawal from Iraq. And now Obama’s media minions are mad, claiming we’re hypocrites for supporting Trump’s withdrawal from Afghanistan after we condemned Obama’s withdrawal from Iraq.

Well, sorry, crybabies, but the hapless and impotent Obama did nothing as ISIS formed its deadly caliphate in that vacuum, which validated everyone’s lack of faith in him and his decision. I just don’t see Trump allowing an international threat to fester anywhere, including Afghanistan.

As the old Vulcan proverb says, “Only Nixon can go to China.”

A fester is certainly a possibility, which is why I mentioned the whole bomb-the-shit-out-of-them thing earlier… Nevertheless, let’s not forget Trump already wiped ISIS out, so he knows how to do this and ISIS and the Taliban know he knows how to do this, and there are always reasons not to do things. You can question everything to death.

But after 19 years, some $2 trillion, and nearly 2500 American fatalities, the only real questions are…

How many more Americans are we going to allow to be picked off year after year after year?

How much more money are we going to pour into a country that cannot be fixed?

How do you liberate people who don’t want to be liberated?

How many years have to pass and how many American have to die before the Neocons admit they were wrong?

Follow John Nolte on Twitter @NolteNC. Follow his Facebook Page here.


Please let us know if you're having issues with commenting.